The game had finished 3-3 in 90 minutes with City, despite controlling large spells of the game, coming from behind on three separate occasion.
The hosts took an early lead through a Leevi Palmula header direct from a corner, with Antton Nylund’s deflected cross cancelling out Charlie Gray’s equaliser before the break.
Reigan Heskey levelled the playing field on the rebound from a saved penalty early in the second half, with Matty Warhurst’s header forcing a shootout after Toivo Mero had once again given the home side the lead.
And Kian Noble was the unfortunate player to see his effort come back off the post, earning Helsinki a 5-4 shootout win in front of almost 10,000 fans.
WHAT HAPPENED
In a minus 11-degree breeze and a light dusting of snow, City’s UEFA Youth League knockout stage journey began.
City looked the brighter side with an early Tyrone Samba shot a warning sign, but Helsinki went ahead on 12 minutes when Palmuma nodded home a dangerous corner that was swung into the back post.
But Wilkinson’s side responded after just five minutes for a deserved goal following patient build-up play.
Christian McFarlane made an underlapping run before the full-back dragged the ball back to skipper Gray, who was perfectly placed to tap home at the near post in a brilliantly worked team move.
As the half-time whistle drew near, City continued to enjoy large spells with the ball whilst Helsinki sat in a compact, low block.
To City’s frustration, a moment of misfortune before the break meant Helsinki regained their lead when Nylund’s cross from the right deflected off Kaiden Braithwaite and floated over Spike Brits.
Wilkinson’s team-talk at half-time clearly provided an extra boost of motivation, with City instantly on the attack.
R. Heskey was tripped on 49 minutes, and the winger fired the resulting penalty down the middle.
And although Helsinki ‘keeper Mitja Haapanen saved the initial effort our winger was quick to tap home the rebound to level the score again.
City had chances to score through Gray as we now searched for the lead for the first time in the match.
But with another rare attack, Helsinki scored again. After a cross from the left from Valo Konttas, Mero did all the work at the back post, firing his effort in from a tight angle.
City still had just over 20 minutes to play, tasked with finding a third equaliser.
And they did just that, four minutes after the restart.
Quick build-up play on the left by McFarlane, T. Samba and R. Heskey saw the latter fire a dangerous cross in and Warhurst rushed forward to head home.
City looked the most likely to find the decisive moment that would win the game, but neither side found a fourth and in turn, the winner was decided via a penalty shootout.
R. Heskey, Gray, Warhurst all dispatched their spot kicks. But Kian Noble’s missed penalty saw Helsinki win 5-4 to draw our Youth League campaign to a close.
HOW WE LINED UP
HJK HELSINKI XI | Haapanen, Traore, Levealahti, Kari, Ameen, Palmula, Le Goff-Conan, Nylund, Konttas, Berisha, Mero.
SUBS | Nittyvirta, Peltola, Zaitra, Gronlund, Zaberxha, De Nascimento, Kesonen, Kroupkin, Salo.
CITY XI | Brits, Nfonkeu, Noble, Braithwaite, McFarlane, Fapetu (X. Parker 63’), Dunbar-McDonald, Gray, Warhurst, T. Samba, R. Heskey.
SUBS | Wint, Drake, Headley, Miles, Sangare, Midwood.
UP NEXT
City’s attention now turns to the Premier League 2.
We take on Leeds United at the Joie Stadium on Saturday 7 February, with kick-off slated for 19:00 (UK).
News about HJK Helsinki v Man City
Watch City's UEFA Youth League trip to HJK Helsinki live on CITY+ today
City's UEFA Youth League Round of 32 match-up with HJK Helsinki will be available to watch live on CITY+ this afternoon. Read more
Wilkinson: We'll take lessons from Helsinki heartbreak
Lead Coach Ben Wilkinson says his players will heed the lessons from our UEFA Youth League Round of 32 exit following our penalty shootout defeat to HJK Helsinki. Watch more
U19s training: Sights set on Helsinki clash
View a selection of training images as City’s Under-19s prepare for our UEFA Youth League Round of 32 trip to HJK Helsinki. View more
Date and kick-off time confirmed for City's UEFA Youth League Round of 32 trip to HJK Helsinki
All the details for City's UEFA Youth League Round of 32 tie against HJK Helsinki have been confirmed. Read more
We’ll use last season’s Youth League experience to guide us this term, says Wilkinson
Lead Coach Ben Wilkinson says he and his side will be using last season’s European experience to help the team in our knockout stage run this term. Watch more
Brits: We’re ready for Helsinki test
City Under-19s goalkeeper Spike Brits says he and his team are ready and raring to go for our latest UEFA Youth League assignment. Watch more